Hindustan Times - The name India trusts for news
Hindustan Times - The name India trusts for newsSaturday, March 31, 2007|23:16 IST
HomeCricket Tabloid HT Next HindustanCinemaTravelJobsMatrimonial ClassifiedsBETA Site
Search Google
Web Site
Your luck today
My HT
4242 New
HT Cricket
HT Tabloid
HT Classifieds
Today's Headlines
Editions
Mumbai
Delhi
Bhopal
Lucknow
HT Next
Hindustan
Links
News
Infotainment
Interactives
HT Specials »
HT Archives »
About Us
Advertise
Investors
Register
HindustanTimes.com » Mandal II muddle »  Story
Keep creamy layer out of quota, says SC

Satya Prakash

New Delhi, February 23, 2007
Advertisement

The Supreme Court has ruled that excluding the creamy layer from among those enjoying the benefits of reservations is a constitutional requirement which cannot be ignored by the Centre or the states.

The creamy layer has been defined under various central and state government notifications for the purpose of excluding those falling under it from the benefits of quota. The children of those holding high government posts or having high income are categorised as belonging to the creamy layer.

On Friday, a bench of justices SB Sinha and PP Naolekar said: “A group of persons although are not as such backward or have by passage of time ceased to be backward, would come within the purview of the creamy-layer doctrine evolved by this court. The court by evolving the said doctrine intended to lay down a law that in terms of our constitutional scheme no group of persons should be held to be more equal than the other group.”

The bench quashed the Justice K.K. Narendran Commission report recommending raising the annual income limit from Rs 1.5 lakh to Rs 3 lakh for the exclusion of the creamy layer from the backward class for the purpose of reservation in Kerala.

The court asked the Kerala government to set up a fresh commission to go into all the aspects of the matter.

The ruling comes at a time when the government is in the process of introducing 27 per cent OBC quota in centrally run or funded educational institutions -- without excluding the affluent among the OBCs.

The decision is already under challenge before the apex court, which has issued a notice to the Centre.

Email Satya Prakash: satya.prakash@hindustanimes.com

Other News Stories »
SC questions validity of 1931 Census for reservations
HRD ministry to deliberate on quota issue
Govt to examine Supreme Court oder on reservation
Post your feedback »
Have Your Say
Feel strongly about something. Have your say here »
Surfer's feedback »
 
Advertisement
Hindustan-HT Cricket-HT Classifieds-HT Tabloid-HT Next - HT Editions-Surfers' Corner
ePaper-Business-Sport-Columnists-Infotainment-Photos-Indians Abroad
E-mail usFeedbackTerms & ConditionsAdvertisements
Asia News  © HT Media Ltd. 2007.  India News
Advertisement
Ad Links
-Call India 3.9c
-Study Abroad
-Travel to Las vegas, Bellagio, Venetian, MGM Grand, Luxor, Mandalay Bay, Aladdin
- Canada drugs, Hotel
- Flowers Singapore
- Get Married
- Dream house